Good decision or lucky outcome? How to learn from your own sailing results
You cut a headland close, saved two miles, and it worked. Was that a good decision? Perhaps, or perhaps you were lucky that the wind stayed on. A good skipper needs to know the difference, because the next time you do that at sea the cost of bad luck may be far higher than a place in a table.
Why results mislead
Sailing mixes skill and chance. If you judge only by how things turned out, you learn the wrong lesson from two kinds of event:
- A risky choice that worked teaches you to take that risk again.
- A sound choice that failed teaches you to stop doing the right thing.
Experienced people call the second one bad luck and carry on. Beginners tend to change everything after one bad day.
Why a long race is such a good teacher
On the water you often never see what would have happened otherwise. In a long online race you can, because:
- every boat is the same, so the difference comes down mostly to decisions;
- every boat has the same wind at the same place and time;
- other skippers have often taken the choice you rejected, so the FLEET list shows you what would have happened;
- your decisions take hours to play out, so you have time to think and to keep notes;
- coming back after a night's sleep, a toast tells you how far she sailed and the places gained or lost.
No race on the water gives you such a clean comparison.
A four-line logbook
Keep this in a notebook or on your phone for each big decision:
| Line | Example |
|---|---|
| What did I know? | Forecast veer in 6 h, 14 kn. Fleet mostly going left. |
| What did I decide, and why? | Go right before the shift. |
| What did I expect? | Gain about 3 NM on the leaders by morning. |
| What happened? | The veer came 4 h late. Lost 1 NM, then gained 4. |
Now ask the useful question: given what I knew then, would I do the same again? If yes, it was a good decision, whatever happened. If you got lucky, write that down too.
The questions that train judgement
- Did I decide, or did I just let it happen? No decision is also a decision.
- Was there a warning I ignored?
- Did I have a way out, or had I bet everything on one forecast?
- Did I decide when tired, or in a hurry?
- What would I need to see next time to change my mind earlier?
From a race to real seamanship
The same habit is what skippers mean by judgement. The stakes change, of course: in a race, an error costs you places, and at sea it can cost much more. So real seamanship has a stronger bias towards safety. When an option has a small chance of a serious outcome, you do not take it, even when it would probably work.
Use the race to train how you think, not the appetite for risk. You can take a chance on a shortcut here because nothing can happen to you. Note that it would be a poor decision with your family on board, and ask yourself why.
An exercise
For the next week write down one decision a day. At the end of the week, sort them into four groups: good and it worked, good and it failed, poor and it worked, poor and it failed. The third group is the one worth reading twice.
FAQ
I keep losing places. Am I making bad decisions?
Not necessarily. Look at the reasoning first, then at several legs rather than one. If you can name the reason behind each loss, you are already learning.
Do I need to do this every day?
No. One well-kept note on a big decision is worth more than a week of watching the table.
Related reading
- Sailing strategy: wind shifts, choosing your side and when to follow the fleet
- Sailing tactics you can train online: laylines, VMG and when to tack
- Think like a skipper: how an online regatta becomes virtual practice for real decisions
- Online sailing regatta simulator — a series of long races round real seas, now THE ROARING NORTH SEA
- COLREG simulator — 54 collision-avoidance exercises on a radar, AIS and bridge-view console, in the browser
- All articles · Open the simulator
Start your virtual practice
Our regatta series is on now with THE ROARING NORTH SEA, and you can join at any time with a SkipperCheck account: real forecast wind, identical boats, in your browser or on your phone. Want a certificate too? Our main course is the VHF course.
Join the race → Try Free Mode →Boat types are described generically; SkipperCheck is not affiliated with any boat builder or class association.